Soup: The Healthiest Comfort Food, or Not So Much? (2024)

Whether you’re sipping warm broth at the office or stirring chicken stew on a snowy day, there’s something undeniably comforting about soup. So warm. So filling. So #wholesome.

Sure, your grandma sang its praises — and you do feel awfully good after a cup ‘o noodles — but what’s the real nutritional value of soup? Is soup healthy? Or is it all in your head?

So, is soup actually good for you?

In most cases, yes!

Most soups are hydrating, filling, and packed with nutrients from veggies, slow-simmered proteins, and mineral-rich broth.

However, some may have unnecessary ingredients and a bunch of salt. So keep an eye on that nutrition label and ingredients to make sure you’re only getting the good stuff.

Was this helpful?

Feeling lukewarm about soup? Grab a spoon and take a seat.

7 ways soup is good for you

Good news! Soups are:

  • nutrient-dense
  • hydrating
  • disease-fighting
  • tummy-filling (great for healthy weight loss!)
  • affordable
  • delicious
  • easy to whip up with a stove, microwave, or slow cooker
Soup: The Healthiest Comfort Food, or Not So Much? (1)Share on Pinterest

1. Soups are nutritious

Think about the last time you cooked chicken or boiled a pot of vegetables. What did you do with the leftover stock? Did you toss it in the sink or trash?

That isn’t a thing with soup.

When soup is made from scratch, it retains whatever nutrients are in the ingredients. You’re getting all the goodness of bone stock (including collagen-packed gelatin) and veggie broth.

Head’s up: Science says the heat from cooking *does* affect vegetables’ vitamin retention — sometimes for better, sometimes worse.

2. Soups are hydrating

Your body is about 60 percent water (that’s why you always have that drip, right?). To keep all systems running smoothly, you need to top up your H2O on the reg.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), your water intake can come from drinks *and* foods.

Whether you’re sipping broth, tucking into a bowl of cabbage soup, or dipping a spoon into creamy chicken noodle heaven (oy yay), you’re also hydrating.

3. Soups might keep the sniffles away

Let’s keep it 100: It’s possible to improve immune function, especially if a person is deficient in nutrients needed for immune function, or if their body is currently dealing with an infection. But there *are* lifestyle habits linked to proper immune system function as a preventative measure.

Healthy habit #1: Eat foods packed with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. A review of 80+ studies found that fruit and veggie intake can be linked to better immune function and reduced inflammation. #winning

Vegetable soup is a great way to boost your overall health and support your immune system. Take tomato soup, for instance. It’s brimming with disease-fighting antioxidants like flavonoids, lycopene, and vitamins C and E.

Will chicken noodle soup cure my cold?

Nope.

Health experts say this salty elixir soothes symptoms (the steamy broth could open congested airways), but it’s no magic cure.

Kicking a cold to the curb requires time, rest, healthy foods, and hydration.

Was this helpful?

4. Soups can support healthy weight loss

Yep, soups can be slimming.

Research has linked soup consumption with a lower risk of obesity. But the same study found that soup-sippers tend to eat more salt. If you’re consuming excessive salt, it could negatively impact your blood pressure.

Soup is also hella filling, which could curb snack cravings. All that broth is like chugging a glass of water with your meal. It’s hydrating and satisfying. To make soup extra, throw in a source of protein like chicken or beans. Protein is the most satiating macronutrient.

5. Soups = all the health perks, fewer calories

Because soup is high in liquid, it’s extra filling. This may help cut down on your overall calorie intake if that’s what you’re after. However, you shouldn’t try soup-only diets to promote weight loss.

These fad diets are typically super low in calories and can end up doing more harm than good when it comes to overall health. Instead, try eating soup before lunch or dinner for a filling, nourishing appetizer or enjoy a bowl of veggie and chicken soup for a nutrient-dense afternoon snack.

6. Soups are easy on the wallet

Unless you’re springing for fancy-schmancy boxed broths, soup is surprisingly affordable. Here’s why:

  • Use up all the food you bought. Next time you’re tempted to toss out wilted kale or a wrinkly potato, stop. Make soup instead!
  • Stretch protein portions into multiple meals. Instead of smashing a whole chicken breast in one go, cube it into a soup tureen that will last for days!
  • Get less takeout. Pro tip: If you want to kick the DoorDash habit, you’ve got to keep more meals in your fridge and freezer. Make a giant batch of soup, then freeze containers for quick, cheap dinners later.

7. Soups are quick and easy

Wanna reach peak #CozyCore in T-minus 5 minutes? Heat up a bowl of your favorite soup.

Or, you could do the following:

  1. Toss some soup ingredients in the slow cooker in the morning.
  2. Set about your day.
  3. Have a warm, nourishing dinner waiting on you like a faithful pupper when you’re ready to wind down. 🐶

Soup is practically prep-free. (You can even nom it for breakfast.)

So, you’re now convinced that soup is cozy AF, simple, and healthy. But what type of soup is the *best* kind?

Tomato soup

🍅

Tomatoes are brimming with healthy plant compounds. From just one tomato, you’ll get:

  • 33 calories
  • 7 grams of carbs
  • 1.6 gram of protein
  • less than 1 gram of fat
  • vitamin C
  • vitamin K
  • vitamin A
  • antioxidants like lycopene

Even better: Tomato soup is great year-round. Try it piping hot in the winter and as a refreshing gazpacho in the summer.

ProsCons
full of vitaminsnot much protein
low fatless filling than creamy, protein-packed soups
tasty all yearsome folks can’t stomach tomatoes’ acidity

Chicken noodle soup

🐔

Chicken noodle soup is a versatile sweater weather classic.

Make it with a creamy base for something extra lush and filling. Or opt for low sodium broth for a heart-healthy bowl of protein, veggies, and carbs.

ProsCon
full of filling, energizing proteintend to be high in sodium (read the label if you’re buying it canned!)
the mix of meat, veggies, and noodles = a complete mealwhite noodles = lots o’ carbs, not much fiber (so try and choose whole-wheat noodles when possible)
the variety of chicken soup recipes means there’s something for everyonecanned varieties often include excess fat, low-quality meat, or added sugar

Creamy soups

🥛🧀

Velvety broccoli-cheddar soup. Luscious chicken or veggie chili. Creamy potato soup. They’re all delicious AF — but come with a hefty dose of calories.

ProsCons
tasty and satisfyingusually high calorie
some are packed with vitamin-rich root veggies (Whole30-friendly soups, anyone?)often high in saturated fat
full of calcium-rich dairycan be full of salt

Miso soup

🍜

One ounce of miso typically has:

  • 56 calories
  • 2 grams of fat
  • 43 percent of your daily recommended sodium
  • lots of manganese, vitamin K, copper, and zinc

Miso is a fermented paste that adds umami flavor to any dish. Sippable in the morning or evening, make it a meal by adding tofu for protein and vegetables or seaweed for vitamins and antioxidants.

ProsCons
typically low in calorieshigh sodium content
vegetarian-friendlyrequires a protein addition to make it a meal

Broth

☕🍖

You make bone broth by simmering animal bones or carcasses in water.

It’s commonly used to give sauces and gravies extra flavor. But you can also warm up a mug of bone broth, chicken broth, or beef broth and sip it as a soup.

ProsCons
contains some minerals like calcium and magnesium (though amounts vary depending on preparation)not suitable as a meal replacement
easy to prepcan be high in sodium
low caloriemore research is necessary to prove marketers’ health claims
warming and soothing on cold days

What to watch out for in soup

Soup-sipping can quickly become high in calories if your soup is full of:

  • salt
  • added sugar
  • cream or cheese

You should also pay attention to portion sizes and avoid overloading a soup with toppings like bacon, shredded cheese, crushed chips, or sour cream.

Was this helpful?

Wanna give soup a whirl? Try some of these tasty, nutritious recipes:

  • white bean, turkey, and kale soup
  • Whole30 soup
  • vegan veggie soup
  • healthy chicken soup
  • seasonal soups that require zero cooking skills
  • 5-ingredient fall soups
  • warming keto soup
  • sweet Hong Kong dessert soup

Is soup healthy? Usually, yes!

Soup can be filling, low calorie, nutrient-dense, and supportive of your immune system and weight loss journey.

Maximize the benefits by avoiding soups that are full of salt, sugar, or cream. Look for soups brimming with vegetables and sources of filling protein and healthy fat instead.

Soup: The Healthiest Comfort Food, or Not So Much? (2024)

FAQs

Are soups the healthiest food? ›

Usually, yes! Soup can be filling, low calorie, nutrient-dense, and supportive of your immune system and weight loss journey. Maximize the benefits by avoiding soups that are full of salt, sugar, or cream. Look for soups brimming with vegetables and sources of filling protein and healthy fat instead.

Is it OK to have soup for dinner everyday? ›

Soup is a good evening meal to have every day because it is typically low in calories and high in nutrients, making it a healthy option for weight management. It is also easy to make and can be customized with a variety of ingredients to suit personal taste preferences.

What are the healthiest comfort foods to eat? ›

Healthier Comfort Foods
  • Comfort Can Be Healthy. 1/11. ...
  • Vegetable Lasagna. 2/11. ...
  • Spaghetti Squash. 3/11. ...
  • Baked Potato With Chili. 4/11. ...
  • Chicken or Black Bean Enchiladas. 5/11. ...
  • Popcorn. 6/11. ...
  • Pretzels With Mustard or Hummus. 7/11. ...
  • Chips and Salsa. 8/11.
Dec 1, 2022

What's the healthiest soup you can eat? ›

6 delicious and healthy soups
  • Chicken Vietnamese Pho.
  • Green spring minestrone.
  • Herb and yoghurt-based soup.
  • Lamb shank and barley soup.
  • Pumpkin soup with star croutons.
  • Lentil and vegetable soup with crusty bread.
Apr 26, 2020

Can you be healthy just eating soup? ›

A delicious bowl of hot soup loaded up with protein and vegetables can be a healthy addition to any eating plan. But a diet that eliminates healthy food groups is generally not recommended for sustainable weight loss or wellness.

Is soup healthy, yes or no? ›

When made with nutrient-rich ingredients, such as vegetables and lean proteins, soup may provide numerous health benefits. However, you may want to watch out for cream-based, canned, and instant soups, as they tend to have a higher calorie and sodium content.

What soup can I eat every day? ›

The key is to stick to lower-calorie, higher-fiber soups like vegetable bean or minestrone. Creamy or other high-fat soups need not apply for this job! A cup of broth- or tomato-based soup only has around 75 to 125 calories (depending on the recipe and type of soup).

Can I replace dinner with soup? ›

Thick soups that carry not only the broth, but also toppings that make them sumptuous, can be had as your dinner. These kind of all-in-one soups, that carry a number of condiments on their side, and ingredients in them, are also a great way of utilizing leftovers.

Is canned soup healthy? ›

Canned soup can be a nutritious, fiber-filled option when you need a quick meal. But some are healthier than others. It's important to look out for sodium content in soups. It's best to choose one with less than 400 mg per serving.

What is the #1 healthiest food? ›

Top 10 Foods for Health
  1. Water. Drink 8 to 12 cups of water daily.
  2. Dark green vegetables. Eat dark green vegetables at least three to four times a week. ...
  3. Whole grains. Eat whole grains sat least two or three times daily. ...
  4. Beans and lentils. Try to eat a bean-based meal at least once a week. ...
  5. Fish. ...
  6. Berries. ...
  7. Winter squash. ...
  8. Soy.

What is the healthiest food to eat all the time? ›

Here are the top 15 foods you should be eating according to our experts:
  • Almonds. ...
  • Mangos. ...
  • Blueberries. ...
  • Mediterranean Diet. ...
  • Chocolate. ...
  • Quinoa. ...
  • Legumes. "Legumes such as chickpeas (garbanzo beans) are a great healthy snack item that can actually provide a lot of flavor depending on how you prepare them. ...
  • Pickled vegetables.
Apr 5, 2019

What is the best comfort food of all time? ›

Our 20 all-time favorite comfort foods
  • 1 of 20. Chicken noodle soup. Joshua Resnick / shutterstock.com. ...
  • 2 of 20. Chicken pot pie. Charles Brutlag / shutterstock.com. ...
  • 3 of 20. Chicken tenders. ...
  • 4 of 20. Chili. ...
  • 5 of 20. Chocolate chip cookies. ...
  • 6 of 20. Cinnamon buns. ...
  • 7 of 20. Cornbread. ...
  • 8 of 20. Fries.
Jun 23, 2024

What are some unhealthy soups? ›

The 5 Worst Soups for Weight Loss (and 5 to Try Instead)
  • Clam chowder. Anything with the word "chowder" in it is probably going to be high in cream, fat, and calories. ...
  • Potato soup. ...
  • Lobster bisque. ...
  • Chili. ...
  • Broccoli and cheese soup. ...
  • Mushroom and barley soup. ...
  • Lumberjackie soup. ...
  • Chilled soups.
Jan 12, 2012

What is the least healthy soup? ›

The 12 Unhealthiest Canned Soups
  • Campbell's Homestyle New England Clam Chowder.
  • Progresso Three Cheese Tortellini. ...
  • Gardein Plant Based Minestrone & Saus'ge. ...
  • Chunky Spicy Chicken Quesadilla. ...
  • Amazon Fresh Chicken Noodle. ...
  • Gardein Plant Based Saus'ge Gumbo. ...
  • Progresso Rich & Hearty Chicken Corn Chowder Flavored with Bacon. ...
Feb 5, 2024

What is the healthiest broth to use for soup? ›

The healthiest bone broth on the market is the Organic bone broth made by Bluebird Provisions because it is the highest protein with 12 grams with 300 mg potassium and no added filler ingredients. It is also low in sodium and tastes absolutely delicious.

Is it OK to go on a soup diet? ›

As the soup diet usually only lasts for 7-14 days, it's not recommended in the long term. The NHS also highlights how very low-calorie diets like this often lead to short term weight loss, but it's likely that you'll put some or all of the weight back on once you go back to eating normally.

Are soups better than solid food? ›

Other research has shown that compared to solid foods like cheese, crackers, and cantaloupe, soup does a better job at curbing subsequent eating. Why soup? Scientists say texture is key. Although liquids empty from the stomach faster than solids, thicker liquids like soup are different.

Can soup replace meals? ›

If you are looking to lose weight, replacing a meal with a bowl of soup can be a great option. However, it is important to make sure that the soup you are consuming is nutritious and contains enough calories to keep you full and energized.

What is the least healthiest soup? ›

What are the least healthy canned soups?
  • Beef stew.
  • Beef stroganoff.
  • Broccoli cheddar.
  • Chicken and dumpling.
  • Clam chowder.
  • Creamy tortellini.
  • Creamy potato.
  • Creamy tomato.
Jul 2, 2024

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Catherine Tremblay

Last Updated:

Views: 5683

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Catherine Tremblay

Birthday: 1999-09-23

Address: Suite 461 73643 Sherril Loaf, Dickinsonland, AZ 47941-2379

Phone: +2678139151039

Job: International Administration Supervisor

Hobby: Dowsing, Snowboarding, Rowing, Beekeeping, Calligraphy, Shooting, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Catherine Tremblay, I am a precious, perfect, tasty, enthusiastic, inexpensive, vast, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.